note: my fictional greeting card to everyone!
Back when I was in middle school, pimply-faced and voice always cracking, I had a crush on this girl. She was in my social studies class and her name was Chloe. She was half-Japanese and half-Irish, so she had green eyes but dark brown hair. She was very pretty and had incredibly smooth and pale skin. We never really spoke to each other except for the one time when we had to work on a group project together. I remember spending a Sunday afternoon at Seth’s house making a collage of West Africa while sitting next to Chloe and cutting up letters from construction paper. She had great control of the scissors and made the neatest letters I had ever seen. She told me that she had a pet cat named Jiro.
The day I started having a crush on Chloe was when I saw her in class on a brisk autumn day. She wore these very shiny cowboy boots that had high heels and a ruffled blouse that gave her a “Western” sort of look. She stood out from all the other girls, and the more I looked at her, the more I just wanted to have her to myself. I didn’t know or learn much about sex until high school, so my attraction towards her was more akin to the attraction that a kitten might have to a shiny object. I couldn’t stop looking at her and I just wanted to play with her.
I was too shy to do anything about my crush, so I just told a few of my close friends how I felt about her. The rest of the time, I sighed to myself and wrote out her name in bubble letters on my marble notebooks. When Christmas time rolled around, I paid a dollar to some club that sent an anonymous candy gram to her saying, “I wish I got to know you better. Happy Holidays!” I wondered for many weeks afterwards how she might have responded to such a message.
When Valentine’s Day rolled around, I decided to finally let her know how I felt about her and started to make an intricate Valentine’s Day card. I bought a thick pack of colored construction paper from the stationery store and tried to be creative, only to realize that I had done nothing more than cut hearts of different colors and sizes. It was hard to escape the prevailing commercial symbol of Valentine’s. A bolt of creativity eventually struck me. I looked through our school yearbook from 6th grade and found a black and white photo of Chloe. I cut out her head and pasted it in the middle of flower petals that I made from paper. The petals could’ve been confused with a lion’s mane, but I added a green stem just to be sure. I then looked for my own school photo and cut my own head out. If you haven’t tried it before, you might want to see how weird it feels to hold a photo of just your own head. I made an oversized bee from strips of yellow and black and placed my head at one end. The card showed a bee, me, hovering around a flower, her. Inside, I wrote: “Catch the buzz? He likes you! Happy Valentine’s!” It was a short and corny message, and I struggled with my decision to address myself in the third person. But the card looked nice by my standards and made me feel a bit confident about my efforts. I put the card into a nice white envelope and took it to school, where I slid it into her locker.
She thanked me the next day when I saw her in class, but didn’t say anything else. That day she wore a white and dark green striped long sleeve shirt with a bright green t-shirt on top. She also had on very bright orange sneakers and dark jeans. I wondered where she got her style. An older sister or a young mother, I guessed.
A few weeks later, she started dating some boy in high school. He would come by our middle school in his Toyota Camry to pick her up after school. I think he was sixteen years old. I thought it was weird because he was three years older, but then I thought that maybe she was too good for boys her own age and needed someone older and more mature. I continued to see her in social studies class but knowing she had a boyfriend made me like her less and less until one day, I stopped paying attention to her. The next year, we weren’t in any classes together, so I hardly saw her around. Whenever I did happen to think about her, I always wondered if she had kept my Valentine’s Day card.
Several years later, when I came back home from college, I caught sight of her at the local supermarket. She was scanning the pudding and yogurt section while I was looking through egg cartons to find the perfect dozen. I recognized her instantly and felt my heart racing at many miles per hour. She looked stunning and more stylish than ever. She turned her head and made eye contact with me, but she didn’t seem to recognize me at all and walked right past me. I didn’t want to embarrass myself so I casually moved on to the bacon section and threw a pack of America’s Choice bacon into my shopping basket. I looked at her backside as she walked gracefully to the checkout line.
Sometimes I wish I had written a bit more in that Valentine’s Day card, maybe telling her a bit about myself and asking her some questions as well. I might recall to the finest detail all of the things she wore back in middle school, but I will never know what kind of books she likes to read, what kind of food she likes to eat, or what kind of music she likes to listen to. I will never know how warm her pale skin feels or how gently she kisses. All I know is that she may or may not still have a card I once gave to her.